Call Today (715) 551-2239

The Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs in the Midwest

The Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs in the Midwest
Are you a homeowner in the Midwest who’s considering a metal roof? Don’t decide until you read this blog with the pros and cons. It may not be the best choice.

When the winds whip across the wide open plains, and the snow blankets the neighborhoods of the Heartland, the steadfast roofs over our heads are not just a luxury—they’re a necessity. These reasons are part of the allure of metal roofing for many midwesterners.

However, the decision to protect your home with metal comes with considerations. Continue reading to explore roofing options for the Midwest. You’ll discover the pros and cons of metal roofs that have become a point of contention.

The Appeal of Metal Roofs

Metal roofing has gained traction in the Midwest for various reasons. Here’s a quick overview of why homeowners like them.


Metal roofs offer a sleek and modern look that can enhance the curb appeal of any home. The reflectivity of metal can also make it an ideal choice for maintaining a cooler home during scorching Midwestern summers.


Metal roofing is durable. With a decades-long life span, metal outlasts many other materials, making it a long-term investment in your property.


Metal roofs are eco-friendly, boasting high recycled content and a fully recyclable status at end-of-life. Their reflective surfaces can contribute to lower urban temperatures and reduced energy use.

Metal Roof Cons

Digging a little deeper, though, uncovers why the Midwest might not be the ideal home for metal roofs.

A Costly Investment

Metal roofs present a substantial upfront cost, deterring homeowners with a strict budget. While the long-term savings are evident, not everyone can take that leap.

Battling Extremes

Midwest weather is nothing if not unpredictable. The rapid temperature fluctuations can lead to “oil canning,” when the metal expands and contracts, causing the roof to appear wavy. This phenomenon doesn’t affect the integrity of the property, but it may not suit every homeowner’s preference.

The Verdict

When it comes to roofing, making an informed decision is paramount. Metal roofing checks many boxes for the Midwest’s diverse climate, but it’s not a unanimous choice. Each home is unique, and the right roof for one may not fit another. That’s why homeowners must consult local experts, understand their needs, and consider the options available. A-Rite is here to help Wisconsin homeowners choose the perfect roof for their home.

There’s good news for those attracted to metal roofs but wary of their drawbacks. GAF provides alternatives that offer some of the benefits while avoiding the challenges of metal roofing in the Midwest. GAF roofing products are at the forefront of roofing technology that can withstand Midwest weather, from architectural shingles to advanced underlayments. Contact A-Rite for all your roofing questions. We’ll help you find the right roof for your house.

Share the Post:

Related Posts